Skip to Site Navigation | Skip to Content

Sept2008

Do Eastern Fertility Treatments Make Western Medicine More Holistic?

From nouveau bell bottoms to resurrected skinny jeans to wide-leg trousers... It's hard to know a passing fad from a true trend toward change, especially in terms of medicine.

In recent years, we've heard so much about holistic therapies for infertility treatment. There's even been an admirable amount of research demonstrating positive effects from what we tend to call "eastern" or even "oriental" medicine. Has it really changed the practice of reproductive medicine?

New Takes on Old Ways
Harvard Medical School is where you'll find decades of research by Herbert Benson, M.D., a key pioneer in highlighting the "relaxation response" and the "mind- body effect." His efforts increased our modern understanding of ancient wellness and healing concepts. One of his protégés was Alice Domar, Ph.D., and she demonstrated how Benson's ideas could be applied specifically to the needs of infertility patients. Practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine were joined by herbalists, homeopaths, naturopaths, and others in the quest to offer what is now often referred to as "holistic" treatment for people struggling to conceive.

A few years ago, I was frequently asked by patients about the validity of these treatment modalities. Now, the buzz from the sudden flurry of books, websites, and new practices has quieted down a bit. Fewer patients inquire, and my response is generally still the same: any type of treatment, no matter from where it originates, is optimal only if tailored specifically to the individual patient's circumstances.

More Than a Fertility Patient


The bottom line for any fertility patient is this: will it help me have a baby, finally?

Just as not all clothing styles look good on everyone, there simply is no one-size-fits-all treatment for infertility.

I am a believer in trying what is not harmful or counter- productive. I have referral relationships with practitioners of various therapeutic realms that can enhance both my patients' experience with and results from conventional medical treatment. I recommend what I believe to be beneficial, using a combination of experience and published research results. I welcome discussion with patients who bring new ideas to my office.

Has the introduction and fluctuating popularity of holistic treatments influenced my reproductive medicine practice? No -- regardless of the tools available, I have always and still consider the patient as a whole person with many interwoven needs. If it works for you, I want you to have access to it.

In Closing


I welcome your thoughts on this and other infertility treatment issues. Please feel free to post comments and at questions on my blog.

Sincerely,

Sonja B. Kristiansen, MD